Politics of States. State of Politics.

So the Government has finally agreed to the formation of Telangana state. Rather, it was forced into submission by a politician who decided to sacrifice his life for the cause.

Does it make sense to have smaller states, maybe city states? Ramesh Srivats has written a very interesting piece and I have commented, largely in agreement.

But the sad part about the decision yesterday was the process that led to it. As ad-hoc and unilateral as ever.

One numbers politician threatens to commit suicide. Everyone watches, waiting to call his bluff. No way, he says, and reaches the edge of the cliff. Centre gulps. High Command weighs political consequences and blinks. Both of them live to fight another day. So this is what democracy is about. 

Of course, the alternative is not a pretty picture too. Creation of a Committee or a Commission, discussing the report a decade later in Parliament, discrediting the people involved, forming a Parliamentary Committee or better still a Joint Parliamentary Committee, discussing the report a couple of years later, discrediting the people involved...... merry go round.

I think I like the suicide err fast unto death approach. Decisions can be taken, either ways, in 12-15 days. Very efficient.

So, if you want your Bangalore city state or Mumbai state, form a party, find a leader who is willing to commit suicide, and attack!

My encounter with the Babus!

I spent a couple of hours this morning at a Registrar's office in Navi Mumbai getting a document registered. During those two hours, there was no electricity in the area: part of the scheduled 3-4 hour load-shedding that is prevalent across all of urban Maharashtra excl. Mumbai (rural areas have longer power-cuts). Many homes and most businesses "beat" the power-cut by using inverters (a crude way of load-balancing, perhaps!), so they don't really bear the brunt of the heat and humidity.

What shocked me today was the observation that Government offices don't seem to have that benefit. Indeed, there was an inverter in the Registrar's office but only to run the PC and printer that was required for the registration activity. Not a single fan was working on this extremely hot and uncomfortable morning. Yet, the officials were all working, without too much of a complaint about the situation - for it must be a regular thing for them. The small office was crowded with people awaiting their turn, multiple parties signing documents and getting them stamped and so on. The sub-registrar, the boss of the place, sat in the centre of all this activity, with a soft smile on his face as he scrutinized agreements worth millions of rupees or marriages (worth much more!), and signed wherever he needed to. Not once during the two hours did I see him lose his temper or get irritated at anyone/anything. There was no way I could have kept my peace or lasted even a day in such an environment.

However, our public servants work in such an environment. Daily. 

There is a lot that is wrong with the Government and the bureaucracy. Productivity is low, and there's corruption everywhere. But, the next time we sit in our air-conditioned offices (or lounges) and pass remarks about how all these babus are lazy and corrupt, spare a thought for those officers sweating it out in dingy, claustrophobic offices, without some of the basic amenities that we take for granted.

A lot needs to change...